MaluNautics

Charter guides

Catamaran or monohull: compare the boats you will actually use

A catamaran has two hulls; a monohull has one. That simple difference shapes the layout, but it does not tell you everything about a charter holiday. Length, age, equipment and the specific design can matter as much as the category. Compare the actual boats on your shortlist rather than treating every catamaran or sailing yacht as interchangeable.

Start with your group's priorities. Some crews want to spend most of the day sailing. Others care more about separate sleeping areas, shared meals and an easy place to gather when the boat is stopped.

Read the layout before counting cabins

Open the deck plan and place each member of your group in a real berth. Check the difference between a dedicated cabin, a saloon conversion and any berth intended for a skipper. Note how people reach the bathrooms and whether one guest must pass through another sleeping area.

On a catamaran, ask how the cabins are divided between the hulls and where the common areas sit. On a monohull, inspect the position and shape of forward and aft cabins. Do not assume that the same cabin count gives the same comfort, storage or privacy. Ask for current photographs of the specific layout you will receive.

Walk through an ordinary day

Imagine breakfast, getting ready to leave, an afternoon aboard and a rainy evening. Where will everyone sit? Is there shade where your group will actually use it? Can people move between the cockpit, saloon and cabins comfortably? If cooking matters, compare the working space and storage rather than simply checking for a galley.

Also think about personal needs. A ladder, step or narrow passage can be important for a guest with reduced mobility. Photographs are useful, but a written answer or video walkthrough from the provider can resolve details that a wide-angle image hides. Explain the need without expecting the boat category to answer it.

Discuss handling and onboard movement

If you will skipper the boat, describe the types and sizes you have handled recently. Ask the provider what introduction is available and which systems differ from those you know. A change in hull arrangement or dimensions is a reason to ask more questions, not proof that one boat is automatically easy.

For guests, discuss the kind of sailing experience they want. Avoid promising that any boat eliminates motion or discomfort. A trial day or a conversation with an experienced skipper can be more useful than a broad claim about stability. The weather, route and how the boat is operated remain part of the experience.

Compare costs at the itinerary level

Compare complete offers for the same dates and group, including any hired skipper's accommodation. Then consider the facilities you expect to use. Ask marinas or the operator about berth suitability and how charges are calculated for the actual boat dimensions; do not apply the price of a smaller vessel to a wider one.

Keep fuel, extras and deposit arrangements visible. A boat that accommodates your group without converting the saloon may justify a different budget, but only if the group values that benefit. Write down the advantage in ordinary language instead of assuming that a more expensive category is automatically a better holiday.

Make the decision with a weighted shortlist

Choose three priorities and rank the real boats against them. For example, a group might prioritise private cabins, space for shared meals and a modest daily route. Another might put sailing participation, a familiar handling setup and overall cost first. Different priorities can reasonably lead to different choices.

If one answer is still missing, keep it as a question for the host. A well-matched boat is more valuable than winning a general debate about catamarans and monohulls.

  • Allocate every berth, including any professional skipper.
  • Compare the shared spaces your group will use each day.
  • Confirm access, storage and shade from the actual boat's details.
  • Check handling requirements and the proposed area with the operator.
  • Compare the complete trip, including suitable overnight stops.

Ready to look at boats?

Use what you have learned to check boat details, dates and the arrangements that matter to your crew.

Explore boats ↗

Keep planning